Home
Buyer's Guides
Product Comparisons
Skid-Steer Loaders vs. Compact Track Loaders: Which Is Right for You?

Skid-Steer Loaders vs. Compact Track Loaders: Which Is Right for You?

Published on

Skid-steer loaders and compact track loaders are compact multi-purpose machines used in construction, landscaping, agriculture, and rentals. They share a similar body and quick-attach systems, but the key difference is the undercarriage: skid steers run on wheels, while track loaders run on rubber tracks. This leads to different performance on various terrains.

The big question is: which machine suits your needs? Generally, skid steers excel on hard, stable ground and in tight working conditions, whereas track loaders excel on soft, rough or slippery ground. This guide will compare both loader types side by side – covering terrain, power, maintenance, comfort and use cases – to help you decide which is right for you.

Quick Side-by-Side Comparison

Skid-Steer Loader – Best for...

Hard, flat surfaces (roads, concrete, gravel)
Confined spaces, tight turns, and quick maneuvers
Lighter loads and frequent moves (fast travel between tasks)
Lower purchase price and fuel/maintenance costs
Abrasive or paved surfaces (tires wear more slowly than tracks)

Compact Track Loader – Best for...

Soft, muddy, sandy, or snowy terrain (excellent traction)
Uneven or sloped sites (superior stability and power)
Heavy-duty tasks (large buckets, forestry tools)
Minimal ground disturbance on turf or soft soil
Rough terrain over long shifts (suspension options improve comfort)

What Is a Skid-Steer Loader?

A skid-steer loader is a small, rigid-frame machine on four wheels that turns by skidding (differential steering). The operator steers by using the joysticks to control the wheels on each side independently. Skid steers are extremely maneuverable and can easily pivot within their own footprint. They typically mount a front attachment such as a bucket, pallet forks, auger, or brush cutter, making them very versatile.

Skid steers use conventional tires, so they are lighter and faster on firm surfaces. Their wheels allow quick travel and agile movements on concrete or gravel jobsites. Typical tasks include dirt/gravel hauling, digging, trenching, pallet handling, and snow removal. With Bobcat’s quick-attach coupler (Bob-Tach®), you can quickly switch between attachments without tools. In short, a skid-steer loader is great for tight spaces, flat terrain, and jobs where speed and versatility are key.

What Is a Compact Track Loader?

A compact track loader (CTL) looks similar to a skid steer but rides on rubber tracks. The track undercarriage spreads the machine’s weight over a larger area, giving it low ground pressure. This lets the machine travel over mud, sand, or snow without getting stuck. Tracks also provide continuous traction, so a track loader can climb slopes and traverse rough terrain where wheels might spin or sink. The operator sits slightly higher for better visibility.

Track loaders offer almost all the same attachments as skid steers (Bobcat uses the same Bob-Tach® system). The big difference is the grip: compact track loaders have superior traction and stability. They are often used for heavy landscaping, forestry, agriculture, and snow removal. Their ample ground contact and even weight distribution mean higher lifting capacity and push force (even on soft ground). However, tracks add weight, making machines heavier and a bit slower to turn, so you trade some travel speed for capability and stability, especially on slopes.

Head-to-Head Comparison

Terrain & Ground Conditions

Skid steers work best on firm, level ground. Their tires concentrate weight on a small area, so they grip tightly on pavement, gravel, and hard soil. On soft or uneven ground, however, wheels can slip or dig in. Compact track loaders spread weight with tracks, giving them substantially lower ground pressure.
In short: skid-steer loaders excel on hard, dry surfaces, whereas compact track loaders shine on soft, wet, or loose ground.

Traction, Power & Performance

Skid steers have a smaller tire contact area, so they generate good push and lift on firm ground. Track loaders, by contrast, have full-length tracks delivering power evenly. As a result, compact track loaders provide more traction and a higher lifting force on rough terrain. This lets them travel through heavy material or climb inclines more easily than a comparable skid steer. However, because skid steers are lighter, they can accelerate faster on hard ground.
In short:

Skid-Steer Loader: good digging and pushing ability on solid surfaces; tires may slip on loose material.
Compact Track Loader: continuous grip yields superior pull/push on mud or snow.

Speed & Maneuverability

Skid steers typically travel faster and turn more sharply. Their lighter weight and simpler driveline let them accelerate quickly and pivot in place. This makes them agile in tight spaces. Compact track loaders usually have a lower top speed and are heavier, so they don’t dart around as fast. However, compact track loaders can still spin and pivot, and their tracks won’t lose traction when turning on slick ground.
In short:

Skid-Steer Loader: faster top speed, very tight turns on firm terrain.
Compact Track Loader: slightly slower travel, but better traction when turning on uneven or slippery terrain.

Operating Costs & Maintenance

Skid steers are generally cheaper to own. A new skid steer typically costs less than a comparable compact track loader. With four tires instead of tracks, routine maintenance is simpler: changing tires is easier and less frequent than servicing a track undercarriage. Bobcat skid-steer loaders also burn a bit less fuel, since they are lighter.

Track loaders require more upkeep: tracks, rollers, and idlers need regular inspection, lubrication, and eventual replacement. If you operate a track loader in harsh conditions, the undercarriage will wear out faster.

Versatility & Use Cases

Both loaders are highly versatile with attachments. Bobcat’s industry-standard Bob-Tach® quick-attach system means the same bucket, forks, augers, or hydraulic tools can be used on either machine. Skid steers are often used for general construction, landscaping, material handling, and snow removal on firm sites. Their compact size suits farmyards, barns, and tight urban jobs.

Track loaders are chosen for jobs involving softer terrain. They thrive in agriculture (muddy fields), forestry (uneven woodlots), utility work (wet holes), and snow clearing. Because tracks float, they do less damage to lawns and can traverse turf with minimal rutting. Compact track loaders can also handle heavy attachments (stump grinders, rock buckets) thanks to better traction. Many contractors even keep both types: a skid steer for hard-surface jobs and a track loader for wet or large-site work.

Comfort & Controls

Modern skid steers and track loaders both offer enclosed, climate-controlled cabs with similar controls. However, the ride feel differs. On hard ground, a tire loader rides smoothly but you can feel bigger bumps. A track loader inherently damps shocks better (especially with optional suspension). Bobcat also provides premium features: the Automatic Ride Control (ARC) system senses a loaded bucket and hydraulically cushions the arms, reducing jolts and spills.

Visibility is excellent on newer Bobcat loaders. The Clear View Cab uses large polycarbonate windows without a mesh barrier, so operators see the bucket and surroundings clearly. Controls and seats are comparable; both have joystick steering and ergonomic adjustments. In summary, track loaders tend to feel a bit smoother over rough ground, while skid steers feel more nimble on smooth surfaces. Bobcat’s comfort features (air-suspension seats, adjustable ergonomics) make either machine pleasant to operate.

Transport & Size

Skid steers are lighter and usually narrower than track loaders in the same class. This makes them easier to haul on smaller trailers and easier to fit through gates or into sheds. Compact track loaders are heavier and slightly wider, so they may require a larger trailer and sometimes oversize permits. If you frequently move machines between sites, consider that a track loader will be a heavier load. Also, tracks cannot be driven fast on highways, so a track loader may require lower travel speeds compared to a skid steer.

Pros and Cons of Skid-Steer and Track Loaders

Skid-Steer Loaders

Compact Track Loaders

Pros

Excellent on paved or rocky surfaces; lower purchase price and fuel/maintenance costs; faster top speed and very tight turning radius; lighter weight (easier hauling); highly versatile with attachments (Bob-Tach® coupler); widely available in rental fleets.

Outstanding traction on mud, snow, and uneven ground; higher lift and push capacity on soft surfaces; smooth ride on bumps (suspension options); highly versatile with attachments (Bob-Tach® coupler); wide tracks float on turf (minimal damage); very stable on slopes.

Cons

Poor traction in mud, sand, or loose gravel; tires can sink in soft ground; less lift/push on slippery slopes; risk of tipping on uneven ground; bumpier ride over rough terrain (no suspension).

Higher initial cost than a skid steer; heavier (harder to transport); slower travel speed; track undercarriage needs frequent maintenance (rollers, idlers, track replacement); tracks wear quickly on pavement.

Which One Should You Choose?

Choose a skid-steer loader if:

You work mainly on hard, stable surfaces (driveways, compacted soil, concrete).
You frequently maneuver in tight spaces or indoors.
You need a faster machine for short jobs and site moves.
You want lower purchase and operating costs (occasional use, rentals).
You prioritize easy transport (lighter weight, smaller trailer).

Choose a compact track loader if:

Your jobsite is often soft, muddy, snowy, or uneven.
You frequently work on steep slopes or delicate turf.
You perform heavy digging, grading, or large-lift tasks.
You can invest more upfront for better performance in tough conditions.
You need to minimize ground disturbance (e.g., landscaping, sod installation).

Bobcat-Specific Advantages

Bobcat machines include several features that address common needs:

Advanced Undercarriage: Many Bobcat track loaders (such as the R-Series models) offer a 5-link torsion suspension undercarriage for an even smoother ride. Both Bobcat skid steers and track loaders can use Automatic Ride Control (ARC) to hydraulically cushion the lift arms, reducing jolts and spills.
Clear-View Cab: Bobcat’s cabs use large, virtually unobstructed polycarbonate windows, giving operators a clear view of the attachment and surroundings.
Attachment Compatibility: All Bobcat loaders use the same Bob-Tach® quick-attach coupler, so buckets, forks, augers, and other tools swap easily between machines.
Easy Maintenance: Bobcat loaders have ground-level service points and tilting hoods. Routine tasks like oil changes and filter swaps are straightforward, helping keep maintenance downtime low.
Dealer Support: Bobcat’s large dealer network across EMEA ensures parts and service are available. Strong resale value also supports the total cost of ownership.

Conclusion

Skid-steer loaders and compact track loaders each have their niches. Skid steers shine on hard, flat terrain where speed and low cost are priorities. Compact track loaders excel in soft, rough, or slippery conditions, offering superior traction and lifting power. The decision isn’t about which machine is “better” overall, but which is better for your work conditions.

If you mostly work on firm ground and need a nimble, cost-effective loader, a skid steer is likely the right fit. If you often face mud, snow or uneven terrain and can afford a higher investment, a compact track loader will pay off in productivity. We recommend testing both types if possible. Talk to your local Bobcat dealer, try operating each on terrain like yours, and review your specific requirements. That hands-on experience will help you pick the best machine for your needs.